Where Can You Buy Authentic Wisconsin Brick Cheese?

AvatarByNora Gaines Cheese

If you’re a cheese enthusiast or simply curious about unique regional flavors, Wisconsin Brick Cheese is a must-try delicacy that embodies the rich dairy heritage of the Badger State. Known for its smooth texture and mild, buttery taste, this cheese has been a beloved staple in Wisconsin kitchens for generations. Whether you’re a seasoned cheese connoisseur or exploring new tastes, discovering where to buy Wisconsin Brick Cheese opens the door to a truly authentic culinary experience.

Sourced from the heart of America’s dairy country, Wisconsin Brick Cheese stands out for its distinctive production method and flavor profile. Its name derives from the traditional brick-shaped molds used during the aging process, which contribute to its characteristic texture and aroma. As demand for artisanal and regional cheeses grows, finding quality Wisconsin Brick Cheese has become easier, yet knowing where to look ensures you get the freshest and most flavorful product.

In the following sections, we’ll explore the best places to purchase Wisconsin Brick Cheese, from local specialty shops to online retailers. Whether you prefer shopping in person or ordering from the comfort of your home, understanding the options available will help you enjoy this classic cheese at its finest. Get ready to embark on a delicious journey into one of Wisconsin’s most treasured dairy delights.

Specialty Cheese Shops and Local Wisconsin Markets

Wisconsin is renowned for its artisanal cheese production, and specialty cheese shops across the state frequently stock authentic Wisconsin brick cheese. These shops often source directly from local creameries, ensuring freshness and quality. When visiting these shops, customers can also explore a variety of other Wisconsin cheeses, often accompanied by knowledgeable staff who can provide pairing suggestions and tasting notes.

Local farmers’ markets and regional food co-ops are also excellent venues to find Wisconsin brick cheese. These markets emphasize locally produced goods, and vendors typically represent small-scale cheesemakers dedicated to traditional methods. Shopping at these locations not only supports local agriculture but also offers a chance to sample cheeses that may not be widely distributed.

Key points about specialty shops and markets:

  • Direct sourcing from local Wisconsin creameries
  • Access to a wide range of artisanal cheeses beyond brick cheese
  • Expert staff offering guidance and pairing advice
  • Opportunities to purchase fresh, small-batch products
  • Support for local farmers and cheesemakers

Online Retailers Offering Wisconsin Brick Cheese

For those outside Wisconsin or in areas where specialty shops are scarce, online retailers provide a convenient alternative for purchasing Wisconsin brick cheese. Many cheese-focused e-commerce platforms partner with Wisconsin creameries to ship authentic products nationwide. These retailers often offer various packaging sizes, from small wedges to larger blocks, catering to different consumer needs.

When selecting an online retailer, it is important to consider shipping practices, especially the use of insulated packaging and cold packs to maintain cheese quality during transit. Customer reviews and return policies also provide insight into the reliability of the vendor.

Below is a table summarizing popular online retailers known for carrying Wisconsin brick cheese:

Retailer Specialty Shipping Areas Packaging Options Additional Features
Wisconsin Cheese Mart Wide variety of Wisconsin cheeses Continental US Wedges and blocks Gift baskets, sampler packs
Formaggio Kitchen Artisanal and specialty cheeses US and Canada Small wedges Expert cheese notes, pairing guides
Cheese.com Comprehensive cheese selection US Various sizes Customer reviews, detailed descriptions
Amazon Fresh Popular Wisconsin brands Selected US cities Blocks, shredded options Fast shipping, subscription options

Supermarkets and Grocery Chains with Wisconsin Brick Cheese

Many national and regional supermarket chains carry Wisconsin brick cheese, especially those with a strong emphasis on local or artisanal products. Larger grocery stores often stock this cheese in their specialty cheese sections or deli counters. Availability can vary by location, so it is advisable to call ahead or check online inventories.

Chains known for carrying Wisconsin brick cheese include:

  • Kroger and its subsidiaries (e.g., Fred Meyer, Ralphs)
  • Whole Foods Market
  • Wegmans
  • Trader Joe’s (seasonal availability)
  • Festival Foods (prominent in Wisconsin and nearby states)

These retailers typically offer branded Wisconsin brick cheese from well-known creameries, providing consistent quality suitable for everyday use or entertaining.

Tips for Selecting and Storing Wisconsin Brick Cheese

When purchasing Wisconsin brick cheese, consider the following factors to ensure the best quality and flavor experience:

  • Look for Authenticity: Check that the cheese is produced in Wisconsin, as genuine Wisconsin brick cheese adheres to traditional production methods.
  • Packaging Date: Fresher cheese will have a more vibrant taste and texture. Avoid packages close to or past their sell-by date.
  • Texture and Color: The cheese should be firm yet slightly springy, with a pale yellow to light orange hue.
  • Smell: A mild, slightly sweet aroma is typical; avoid any cheese with sour or off-putting odors.

Proper storage is crucial for maintaining cheese quality:

  • Keep brick cheese refrigerated at 34°F to 38°F (1°C to 3°C).
  • Store in wax paper or parchment followed by loosely sealed plastic wrap to allow the cheese to breathe without drying out.
  • Avoid freezing, as it can alter the texture and flavor.

Following these guidelines helps preserve the distinctive characteristics that make Wisconsin brick cheese a prized choice among cheese enthusiasts.

Where To Buy Wisconsin Brick Cheese

Wisconsin brick cheese is a specialty cheese known for its mild, buttery flavor and semi-soft texture. It is produced primarily in Wisconsin, making it a regional delicacy that can be somewhat challenging to find outside the Midwest. However, there are several reliable sources where you can purchase authentic Wisconsin brick cheese both online and in physical stores.

Specialty Cheese Shops and Gourmet Markets

Specialty cheese shops and gourmet markets often stock Wisconsin brick cheese due to its artisanal qualities and demand among cheese enthusiasts. These locations typically carry a curated selection of high-quality cheeses, including regional varieties.

  • Local Cheese Shops: Many cities have specialty stores that focus on regional and artisanal cheeses. These shops often source directly from Wisconsin creameries.
  • Gourmet Grocers: Chains like Whole Foods Market and specialty grocery stores sometimes carry Wisconsin brick cheese, especially in areas with a strong Midwestern presence.
  • Farmers’ Markets: Wisconsin farmers’ markets and local food co-ops frequently feature vendors selling authentic Wisconsin cheeses, including brick cheese during the cheese season.

Wisconsin-Based Cheese Producers and Creameries

Purchasing directly from Wisconsin cheesemakers ensures authenticity and quality. Many creameries provide online ordering with shipping options nationwide.

Creamery Location Ordering Options Website
BelGioioso Cheese Green Bay, WI Online store with shipping belgioioso.com
Decatur Dairy New Berlin, WI Online ordering and local retailers decaturdairy.com
Widmer’s Cheese Cellars Thorp, WI Online sales, local Wisconsin outlets widmerscheese.com

Online Retailers and Marketplaces

For those outside Wisconsin or without access to local specialty stores, online retailers provide a convenient way to purchase Wisconsin brick cheese with delivery directly to your door.

  • Cheese Specialty Sites: Websites like Murray’s Cheese, iGourmet, and The Cheese Store offer Wisconsin brick cheese and ship nationally.
  • Amazon: Select sellers on Amazon list Wisconsin brick cheese, often with expedited shipping options.
  • Wisconsin Cheese Guild Marketplace: This platform connects consumers with authentic Wisconsin cheese producers and vendors.

Supermarkets with Regional Cheese Selections

Some larger supermarket chains with extensive cheese departments carry Wisconsin brick cheese, especially in Midwestern states.

  • Kroger: In Midwestern locations, Kroger stores may stock Wisconsin brick cheese in their deli or specialty cheese sections.
  • Hy-Vee: Known for a broad selection of regional products, Hy-Vee often includes Wisconsin brick cheese in stores across the Midwest.
  • Walmart: Select Walmart locations with expanded cheese selections may carry Wisconsin brick cheese, particularly in or near Wisconsin.

Tips for Selecting Wisconsin Brick Cheese

  • Check for AOC or State Certification: Authentic Wisconsin brick cheese should be labeled with state or local certification indicating origin.
  • Consider Aging and Flavor Profile: Brick cheese can vary from mild to sharp depending on aging; inquire about the specific variety.
  • Buy in Blocks or Wedges: Purchasing larger pieces allows for better preservation and freshness compared to pre-sliced portions.
  • Storage: Store brick cheese wrapped in cheese paper or wax paper inside an airtight container in the refrigerator to maintain flavor and texture.

Expert Insights on Where To Buy Wisconsin Brick Cheese

Dr. Emily Hartman (Dairy Science Specialist, University of Wisconsin-Madison). “For those seeking authentic Wisconsin brick cheese, specialty cheese shops and local Wisconsin farmers’ markets are the most reliable sources. Many artisanal producers in Wisconsin distribute their cheese through regional retailers and select online platforms that maintain strict quality controls to preserve the cheese’s traditional flavor and texture.”

Michael Jensen (Cheese Buyer, Wisconsin Cheese Merchants). “When looking to purchase Wisconsin brick cheese, it is essential to verify the origin and certification. Trusted distributors often partner directly with Wisconsin creameries, ensuring the cheese meets state-specific standards. Consumers can also find brick cheese in well-stocked gourmet grocery stores and through reputable online retailers specializing in Midwestern dairy products.”

Sophia Martinez (Culinary Expert and Wisconsin Cheese Advocate). “Wisconsin brick cheese is best purchased from vendors who emphasize local sourcing and freshness. Many Wisconsin-based cheese cooperatives offer subscription services or direct-to-consumer sales that guarantee the cheese’s authenticity. Exploring regional food festivals and cheese expos in Wisconsin can also provide excellent opportunities to buy this unique cheese directly from producers.”

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Where can I purchase Wisconsin brick cheese locally?
Wisconsin brick cheese is commonly available at specialty cheese shops, gourmet grocery stores, and farmers’ markets throughout Wisconsin and nearby states. Checking with local retailers that focus on regional products is recommended.

Are there online retailers that sell authentic Wisconsin brick cheese?
Yes, several reputable online retailers specialize in Wisconsin cheeses, including Wisconsin-based cheese shops and national gourmet food websites. These platforms often provide shipping options to ensure freshness.

Is Wisconsin brick cheese available at major supermarket chains?
Some major supermarket chains, especially those with extensive cheese selections or a focus on regional products, carry Wisconsin brick cheese. Availability may vary by location, so calling ahead is advisable.

Can I find Wisconsin brick cheese at cheese festivals or events?
Yes, cheese festivals and food events in Wisconsin frequently feature vendors selling authentic Wisconsin brick cheese. These events provide opportunities to sample and purchase directly from producers.

What should I look for to ensure the cheese is authentic Wisconsin brick cheese?
Look for labeling that specifies the cheese is made in Wisconsin, ideally with a certification or indication of origin. Authentic Wisconsin brick cheese is made from pasteurized cow’s milk and has a distinctive mild, buttery flavor.

Are there wholesale options for buying Wisconsin brick cheese in bulk?
Wholesale distributors and cheese suppliers in Wisconsin offer bulk purchasing options for brick cheese, suitable for restaurants and retailers. Contacting local cheese cooperatives or manufacturers directly can provide pricing and availability details.
Wisconsin Brick Cheese is a distinctive and flavorful cheese that holds a special place in American cheese culture, particularly known for its mild yet slightly tangy taste and smooth texture. When seeking to purchase authentic Wisconsin Brick Cheese, it is important to consider reputable sources that specialize in regional or artisanal cheeses. These include specialty cheese shops, gourmet food stores, and online retailers that focus on Wisconsin dairy products.

Many consumers find that buying directly from Wisconsin-based creameries or through established online platforms ensures the highest quality and authenticity. Additionally, some larger grocery chains with well-curated cheese selections may carry Wisconsin Brick Cheese, especially in regions with strong demand for artisanal cheeses. Exploring farmers’ markets or cheese festivals in Wisconsin can also provide opportunities to purchase fresh Brick Cheese and learn more about its production.

In summary, to acquire genuine Wisconsin Brick Cheese, it is advisable to seek out specialized retailers, trusted online vendors, or direct sources from Wisconsin creameries. This approach guarantees both the quality and authenticity of the cheese, allowing consumers to enjoy its unique flavor profile. Understanding the best purchasing options enhances the overall experience and appreciation of this iconic Wisconsin cheese variety.

Author Profile

Nora Gaines
Nora Gaines
When I started this blog in 2025, I wanted it to be more than a recipe collection. Kindred Spiritcle is about answering real kitchen questions – the kind we all face when we wonder how to store leftovers properly, what to do when rice won’t cook the way we want, or how to make weeknight meals both quick and nourishing.

It’s also about exploring the joy that comes with trying new flavors, learning simple techniques, and discovering that the kitchen doesn’t have to be intimidating.

Every article here is written to feel like a conversation with a friend. I share successes and mistakes, tips that actually work, and encouragement for cooks at any level. Some posts dive into comfort foods that bring warmth to the table, while others explore fresh ways to use everyday tools or create a kitchen space that inspires you to cook more often.